March 1, 2013
By now, many of us have heard about the controversy over Yahoo CEO Marissa Mayer’s recent ban on employees working remotely. In a company-wide memo, they explained that in order to “become the absolute best place to work, communication and collaboration will be important, so we need to be working side-by-side. That is why it is critical that we are all present in our offices. Some of the best decisions and insights come from hallway and cafeteria discussions, meeting new people, and impromptu team meetings. Speed and quality are often sacrificed when we work from home. We need to be one Yahoo, and that starts with physical being together.”
At Innovatively Organized, this has been a hot topic of discussion in our office. We are a company that values flexibility and remote working, but we also value our frequent team meetings and collaborating on-site; there are benefits and challenges to both sides of the debate. It is not a black and white issue and what works for one company, may not work for the next.
Pros of Yahoo’s ban:
- Gets employees talking more and being more collaborative
- Allows decisions to be made faster
- Stops employees from feeling isolated
- Disables any unproductive habits produced from working at home
Cons of Yahoo’s ban:
- Disrupts positive routines that employees may have working from home
- Employees will now lose time commuting to work
- More distractions can occur in the workplace with everyone working side-by-side
Other Options That Could Have Been Considered:
- Review technology options for collaborative virtual meetings
- Provide training on how to be productive when working from home
What Others Are Saying:
“If culture and innovation are important to the success of your company then working with colleagues IN an office - at least most of the time - is important. One caveat - if working from home is a benefit that can help recruit top technical talent then it makes sense to use it. Call centers and other non-innovation-based positions can actually be more productive when done from home and should be considered.”
- Daniel Rossi, Northwest Entrepreneur Network, @NWEN_org
“Employees today need choice and control over where and how to work. Choice and control means giving workers a ‘palette of places’ – zones to play, socialize, concentrate, collaborate or create in the physical work environment in combination with some latitude in working from outside of the office, whether that’s at home or at a coworking place. We’ve seen that having options is key to a company’s productivity, creativity and wellness.”
- Jimmy Kwan, Turnstone, @cultofkwan
“This is a reminder that we really need to stop and think hard about sweeping social changes. Working from home is an attractive option for many reasons, but there are significant cultural issues. I would share Mayer’s concern about the lost productivity, creativity, and relationship potential that results from an at-home workforce, but I don’t know what kind of science or analysis went into the decision to ban the practice outright.”
- Jim Hessler, The Boss Show, @TheBossShow
Regardless of which side of the debate you fall on, or what your work environment is, our primary goal is for you to work productively. Here are a few productivity resources for people who telecommute or work in a traditional office.
Telecommuting Productivity Resources:
Mobile Professionals Checklist, Going As Paperless as Possible, A Time Management Tip You Can Implement Today
Traditional Office Environment Productivity Resources:
10 Personality Quirks That Make Your Office Unproductive, Time Management Advice for Bosses, Avoiding Distractions
What are you thoughts on the work-from-home debate? We’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments.